WHAT DID THIS UNION DO WRONG?

Here are the facts. See if you can figure out two things the union did wrong.  The agency had a practice of placing a guard at each of its strategically important locations around its property every shift.  When it suddenly changed that by requiring one staff person to cover two strategic locations per shift rather than one, the union charged management with violating the contract.  The clause at issue read as follows: “The Employer agrees to lower inherent hazards to employees to the lowest level possible without relinquishing its management rights.  A ‘strategic location’ is defined as a self-contained area and can only be safely secured by a single officer.”  The union grievance asked for a return to the prior staffing level and that is what the arbitrator ordered. However, FLRA overturned the award saying that it intruded too heavily on management’s right to assign work.  Have you identified the two errors yet? Continue reading →

Posted in Grievance/Arbitration | Tagged | Leave a comment

REINSTATED DESPITE 939 HOURS OF UNSCHEDULED LEAVE IN ONE YEAR

This employee worked only three full pay periods over the course of a year. In all the others, he called in from home or wherever to ask for annual, sick or whatever kind of leave the agency would grant him, including AWOL. The agency put him on leave restriction letters twice during that time and suspended him twice for a total of 17 days without pay for failure to follow proper leave procedures and the suspension notices “clearly state[d], ‘[y]ou are cautioned [that] any repetition of this or similar offenses may result in more severe disciplinary action against you’” for not following leave procedures. Finally, they fired him in June 2016. Most union reps would look at those facts and conclude that the best thing they could do for this guy is get him a clean record if he resigns. But they would be wrong because the MSPB said he should be reinstated. See Christopher M Robinette v. Dep’t. of the Army, MSPB Doc. No. AT-0752-16-0633-I-1 (May 11, 2022) Here is why. Continue reading →

Posted in Discipline/Adverse Action, Leave | Tagged | Leave a comment

RESTORING UNION COLLECTIVE BARGAINING STATUS—HOSTAGE STYLE

With the resounding election repudiation of all things Trump, unions should now be in a much better position to get their bargaining, time, and arbitration rights restored. Demanding a bill to override the President’s power to exclude units sounds like a waste of time. It will take a year or so, probably be vetoed, and even if passed challenged for  years in the courts. Continue reading →

Posted in Bargaining Law | Tagged | 2 Comments

CREATIVE GRIEVANCE REMEDIES

One of the criticisms that can be leveled against most unions is that they often file grievances that fail to pursue all the potential remedies an employee is due.  To put it more bluntly, they are letting an agency off too lightly.  As we see it, when agencies get hit with extensive remedy orders they are less likely to fight similar grievances all the way in the future; they start looking for early settlements.  So, we have devoted more than a few lines of print to remedies, e.g., Grievance Strategy Issues (Remedies).  We just came across an EEOC decision which went to great lengths to give the employee all the remedies she was entitled to, and we want to pass along an excerpt of the case so you can see all the corrective actions that are possible and legal when you include an alleged EEO violation in your grievance. Even if you can’t sustain an EEO violation, the list of remedies in this case should be considered whenever grieving.  LET’S END OF VIRTUALLY USELESS GRIEVANCE MERELY ASKING FOR A CEASE AND DESIST ORDER. EEOC wrote as follows, but we added the underlining: Continue reading →

Posted in Grievance/Arbitration, Remedies | Tagged | Leave a comment

“INTERACTIVE PROCESS” APPLIES TO RELIGIOUS ACCOMMODATION REQUESTS, TOO

All too often managers reply to employee requests for a work accommodation with a quick “No” or “HR said no.”  A large bundle of case law holds that it violates law to dismiss a disabled employee’s request for an accommodation without exploring options in a back and forth communication.  It is called the “interactive process.”  We have written about it often. When managers fail to do this, they make it very easy for employees to win claims of disability discrimination with cash payouts. Although it is a smaller bundle of case law, precedent also holds that managers owe employees requesting accommodations for religious purposes the same quality of interaction.  The folks at the Constangy Brooks Smith & Prophete law firm posted a good article explaining all this that union reps should find helpful. Click here to read it in about 3 minutes time.

This is also something you should pass on to your members, most of whom have little to no idea what the union can do for them because they do not know their rights.

Posted in Reasonable Accommodations, Religion | Tagged | Leave a comment

REASSIGNMENT RIGHTS TO TELEWORK-APPROVED JOBS

If an agency has terminated your right to telework, do you have the right to be reassigned to a job that does permit telework? Continue reading →

Posted in Disability, Reasonable Accommodations, Telework | Tagged | Leave a comment

YET ANOTHER SEXUAL HARASSMENT CASE

It is a mystery why agencies still do not seem to understand what sexual harassment looks like. In a recent EEOC case, the facts showed that for nine months an employee was subjected to, “unwelcome touching such as hugging, pressing himself against Complainant, and attempting to massage her, inappropriate comments about her appearance, asking her out on a date multiple times, aggressively asking her for her address, harassing messages, and texting her when he drove past her house.” What was so tough about recognizing that as a violation of civil rights law?  In the end, EEOC ordered the agency to pay the employee $95,000.00. If unions publicized these cases among unit employees, members might not only get some justice, but sensitivity to the issues might also trickle down to managers. For more details on this case, check out Kasie L., v. Douglas A. Collins, Secretary, Dep’t. of Veterans Affairs, EEOC No. 2025003799 (2026)

Posted in Sexual harassment | Tagged | Leave a comment

BIG MONEY FOR TELEWORK GRIEVANTS?

We have reminded readers several times that when they grieve telework denials they should ask to be reimbursed for the mileage they racked up coming to the office when they should have been allowed to work from home.  EEOC issued a recent decision that might help unions convince managers and arbitrators that mileage reimbursement is allowed when employees are forced to commute in violation of an agency obligation. Continue reading →

Posted in Remedies, Telework, Travel/Per Diem | Leave a comment

“PROVE YOU ARE RELIGIOUS OR ELSE”

When Alisia, a VA employee, asked to have every Sunday off to practice her religion, management asked her to prove that she actually participated in religious activity.  More specifically, it wanted the name and address of her house of worship. (Were they going to contact the pastor to confirm she showed up in a pew each week?) And until she coughed that information up it was not going to grant her a religious accommodation. Alisia gave them an EEO charge instead that was just decided by the EEOC addressing whether or when employers can demand employees prove their religious activity. It wrote: Continue reading →

Posted in Religion, Uncategorized | Tagged | Leave a comment

SUPERVISOR VERSUS CO-WORKER SEXUAL HARASSMENT

Are your legal protections different between them?  YUP!  The Solomon Law Firm did a good job in laying out the differences and we recommend that you take use a few minutes to read through what they have to say. You could also circle back to review a piece we posted this summer outlining what the EEOC says about co-worker harassment. You might also want to refresh your recollection about what we said in 2023 about how it is easier to prove discriminatory retaliation or reprisal than harassment.

Posted in Co-worker Harassment, Retaliation | Tagged | Leave a comment