RATING PANEL GRIEVANCES: WE HAVE SAID IT BEFORE AND HERE IT IS AGAIN
Attacking the scores of a promotion rating panel is hard to do under traditional labor law. But, if you can find a reason to allege that there was not just a violation of a contract provision, such as the need for all promotion actions to be “systematic and equitable,” but also an EEO violation, you have a better chance of winning the case. EEO case law requires agency rating panels to carry a burden that most contract grievances do not. The latest example of this is a case (David T. v. Megan Brennan, Postmaster, EEOC No. 2019001172 (2019)) that resulted in an employee getting retroactively promoted and compensatory damages in addition to back pay. EEOC said the rating panel members “failed to provide any specificity when asked why successful candidates were recommended and why Complainant was not.” EEOC demands a lot of specificity that contract grievance arbitrators do not. For example, EEOC wrote … Continue reading