GOOD NEWS ABOUT DOUGLAS FACTORS 6 & 10
Homeland Security fired a Deportation Officer because he traveled home from an assignment in Chile a day earlier than scheduled and spent the day with his family. DHS also cited the fact that he falsified some travel and overtime documents. AFGE took the case to arbitration only to lose. The case then was appealed to the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals where the court criticized the arbitrator for not thoroughly examining these two Douglas factors. The case should help unions demand more thorough and legitimate consideration of Douglas Factors by agency deciding officials and arbitrators. You can read the decision yourself at Torres v DHS, Fed. Cir. No. 22-2003 (2023), but here is our brief take on why it is valuable. Continue reading